My team is here to serve. Our unique backgrounds, training and experience have prepared us well to help meet your insurance needs. Additionally, as residents of your community, we understand how important it is to be there for you - our trusted friends and neighbors. Together, we're building strong partnerships that help everyone succeed.

  • :
  • English
a group of people posing for a photo
a man with a beard

Jeremiah Reader

Sales Specialist – All Lines
Jake grew up just outside of Beaver Dam. He spent many years working in the construction trades, most recently in the Operating Engineers Local 139 as a certified crane operator. He came to the insurance world this year and is actively growing his knowledge in farm/ranch policies to better provide for our rural community. He enjoys his free time with his wife and kids on a small farmette.
Karen Goodfellow wearing glasses

Jessica Mahnke

Customer Loyalty Specialist
Jesi has been with American Family for 4 years as an Agent Assistant and has really been enjoying getting to know our insureds. My husband and I have lived in Beaver Dam for about ten years and are now new to the world of having no kids in the house. With this new change I have been trying out different hobbies, now that I have the time! I also really enjoy walking outside when the weather is nice
a woman with a scarf around her neck

Melissa Gritzmacher

Office Manager
Missy has been with American Family as an Agent Assistant since 2007. She has lived in Beaver Dam since 1993 with her husband, Max, and two daughters, Madelyn and Makenzi. In her free time, she enjoys spending time with family and friends, and supporting both girls with all of their extra-curricular activities!